With years of combined expertise in online publishing, OvertimeReviews embodies the lessons learned from SEO strategies to paid advertising experiences. We've navigated the highs and lows, and our goal remains clear: to equip readers with comprehensive information they can trust.
The Best Softball Gloves of 2025
Written By OvertimeReviews Team
To take your softball game to the next level and ensure your team dominates on the field, investing in a high-quality softball glove is essential. Not only can it help you catch more balls, but it can also prevent injuries and improve your overall performance. That’s why we’ve put together a comprehensive review of the best softball gloves available in 2025.
We’ve carefully selected gloves to fit every budget and skill level, ensuring that you’ll find the perfect glove to enhance your game. After thorough research, the Franklin Sports glove earned the top spot on our list for its superior quality and comfortable fit.
The Best Softball Gloves
Franklin Sports Softball Glove
Best Overall
The Franklin Sports softball glove is the perfect choice for softball players of all levels. This high-quality glove is available in five colors and various sizes to suit any player’s needs. Made from soft synthetic leather, it’s easy to break in and offers superior comfort and durability. The adjustable wrist strap with thumb adjustment ensures a secure fit for all players, allowing you to focus on your game without any distractions.
Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced player, this softball glove is a solid choice. It will contour your unique shape, making it an extension of your own hand on the field. It’s an ideal choice for anyone who wants a high-quality glove that is comfortable, durable, and well-made. Due to its highly adjustable wrist straps and soft synthetic leather, it earned its place at the top of our list.
Rawlings Softball Glove
Most Comfortable
The Rawlings softball glove is an excellent choice for recreational players who want a reliable and durable glove. With a 12.5-inch size, this glove is versatile and perfect for baseball and slowpitch softball, making it suitable for any position on the field. It features a basket web and quality full-grain leather for maximum durability. The Zero Shock palm padding provides extra impact protection, and the adjustable wrist strap ensures a customizable fit for greater comfort.
Not only is this glove excellent in terms of ergonomics and build quality, but it also offers a quick and easy break-in process, making it game-ready right out of the box. The durable leather ensures it can withstand wear and tear for many seasons, and the adjustable strap guarantees a perfect fit every time. It’s an optimal choice for performance enhancement and reliable, long-term use.
Wilson Softball Glove
Beginners Pick
For any young softball player, the Wilson softball glove is perfect for practice and match day. Made from high-quality leather and featuring a quick-fit wrist for a secure fit, it’s both stylish and functional with its neutral black, blonde, and white colors. The size options are ideal for young players to handle, and the H-Web design provides maximum stability while fielding. It has a great feel for catching both hard-hit balls and smooth fly balls and is designed to provide maximum dexterity and flexibility of movement in all positions on the field.
The Pittard’s palm lining in the interior of the glove absorbs perspiration and keeps the hand cool and dry during long practices or games. The lightly padded finger stalls offer extra comfort, and the adjustable wrist strap ensures a snug fit that won’t slip or move during play. With its stylish design and comfortable fit, this glove will help young players look and feel their best while playing their favorite sport.
Mizuno Softball Glove
Fastest Break-In
The Mizuno softball glove is a top-performing option. Constructed with full-grain leather, it’s both durable and comfortable thanks to Mizuno’s Mzo lining, which disperses perspiration for extended wear. The Polyurethane power lock ensures a secure fit with the flexibility provided by the PU pull tab. The thumb-cut hinge increases flexibility, making this glove perfect for any female fastpitch softball player.
The quality construction of this glove ensures superior performance and longevity on the field. The leather provides great durability and resilience, while the Mzo lining keeps hands comfortable by wicking away moisture. The Polyurethane power lock offers an excellent fit for an ideal grip on the ball, giving players the ability to take game-winning catches. This design brings out the best in every ambitious fastpitch softball player with increased comfort, superior performance, and enhanced flexibility.
Miken Softball Glove
Best Protection
The Miken softball glove is a top-notch choice for both recreational and competitive adult slow-pitch softball players. Constructed with full-grain leather, it delivers exceptional durability, shape retention, and season-after-season performance. Its adjustable quick-release wrist pull strap system ensures a custom fit and comfortable experience for every user. Additionally, the Poron XRD palm and index finger pads provide significant impact reduction and long-lasting structure.
This softball glove has a short break-in period with a 90% factory break-in, so it’s game ready right out of the box. Its versatile design makes it suitable for both left and right-handed throwers, making it accessible to players of all skill levels. Designed with quality in mind, this glove ensures longevity even with intensive regular use. Its unique combination of materials offers the best balance between comfort and performance, allowing players to make their plays with confidence while maintaining quality and protection.
Buying Guide: Softball Gloves
A good softball glove can make all the difference in catching a pop fly or making a game-changing catch. But out of so many options available, how do you decide which glove is the perfect fit for you? In this buying guide, we have listed out the features of a good softball glove, and what to look for when making a purchase to ensure you make an informed decision and find the perfect glove for your game.
Size
Choosing the right size glove is crucial when it comes to playing softball. Gloves come in a range of sizes, from 10” to 17” for adults and 8” to 13” for young players. It’s essential to find a glove that fits the player’s hand properly, allowing them to move and catch the ball with ease. For young players, select a glove that provides room for growth. Adults should look for a glove that fits snugly and comfortably.
Position
Your position on the field determines the type of softball glove that best suits you. Infielder gloves are smaller than those of outfielders and pitchers, with light, open webbing for quick ball closure. Pitcher’s gloves have extra padding around the wrist area and deeper pockets to secure the ball better when throwing.
Material
Softball gloves can be made from either leather or synthetic materials. Leather gloves provide a classic look and feel and generally allow for more customization with break-in periods and lacing. Synthetic gloves offer flexibility and durability, making them ideal for beginners who may not have experience with break-in periods or lacing leather gloves. In either case, make sure you choose a material that is comfortable and sturdy enough for your game.
Webbing
To select the right softball glove, consider the type of webbing. Quick closing on the ball requires open-weave webbing for infield or outfield play, while heavier webbing is preferable for hard pitches or throws. Comfort is important—ensure your fingers fit comfortably in the pocket without squeezing.
Padding
Consider the padding in the pocket and around your fingers when choosing a softball glove. A well-padded pocket and finger area offer comfort and safety while playing. Choose durable padding that meets your needs for long-lasting use.
Break-in Period
Not all gloves require an extensive break-in period before being used, but some do require more time and effort than others before they are usable on the field. If you choose a glove that requires more time to break-in than others, make sure that you give yourself enough time before game day to ensure proper fitment and comfort when playing.
Craftsmanship
Consider the craftsmanship of the glove before buying it. Look for reinforced stitching in critical areas like the webbing, palm, and fingers, and materials that are well-cut and durable. Ensure that the lacing on leather gloves is strong enough to withstand prolonged use without needing repairs or replacements.
Comfort
Comfort is essential when buying a softball glove since an ill-fitting glove can hamper performance regardless of its quality. Look for gloves that fit comfortably and snugly, with minimal bunching in key areas like the fingers and webbing. Additionally, ensure there is enough padding around important areas like the wrist and fingers for added safety during play.
Brand Reputation
Lastly, read customer reviews to gain insight into the brand’s product line and customer service. This ensures that you select a reliable brand with good customer service and support if issues arise during use.
People Also Asked
What is the best size for a softball glove?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question as the best size for a softball glove depends on the player's position and age. In general, adult infielders tend to prefer gloves between 11” and 12”, while outfielders tend to prefer gloves between 12” and 14”. Younger players typically use gloves between 9” and 11”, with infielders using slightly smaller gloves than outfielders.
What is the difference between a youth and an adult softball glove?
The main difference between a youth and an adult softball glove is the size. Youth gloves are typically smaller to fit the hands of younger players, while adult gloves are larger to fit the hands of adult players. Additionally, youth gloves are often made with less expensive materials and may have a simpler design, while adult gloves are typically made with higher-quality materials and have more features for better performance.
Is there a difference between softball gloves and baseball gloves?
Softball gloves are larger with deeper pockets to accommodate the larger softball and are usually made with thinner leather to make them lighter. Baseball gloves are smaller with shallower pockets to accommodate the smaller baseball and are made with thicker leather for increased durability. The webbing on baseball gloves is usually tighter to secure the ball, while softball gloves have looser webbing for easier catching of the larger softball.
How long does a softball glove last before needing to be replaced?
The lifespan of a softball glove can vary depending on usage and care. With proper care, a high-quality softball glove can last for many seasons. A heavily used glove may need to be replaced after a few years, while a less frequently used glove may last for a decade or more.
Are there any special care instructions I should follow when caring for my softball glove?
Yes. You should keep it clean and dry to prevent mold and mildew, avoid exposing it to extreme heat or cold and store it properly by keeping a ball in the pocket and wrapping it with a rubber band or glove wrap to maintain its shape. Additionally, you should condition the leather with specialized glove oil to keep it supple and prevent cracking.
How do I break in my softball glove properly?
To break in your softball glove properly, first, apply a small amount of glove oil or conditioner to the leather. Then, use a mallet or baseball to hit the pocket of the glove repeatedly to loosen the leather. You can also wear the glove and repeatedly open and close it to help break it in. Remember to take your time and avoid using excessive force to avoid damaging the glove.
Trustworthy Insights for You
Contributors
We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Click here to learn more about our process.